REVIEW: The History of Concrete

Concrete
3.5 out of 5 stars (3.5 / 5)

There’s something peculiarly comforting about watching a film that you have no idea where it’s going, particularly when its director seems just as uncertain.

John Wilson’s The History of Concrete begins with the filmmaker at something of a loose end. His acclaimed HBO series How To with John Wilson has ended, the royalties are dwindling, his agent appears increasingly reluctant to take his calls, and a world in which AI can imitate his distinctive voice presents some awkward questions about the commercial value of being John Wilson. Somehow, this leads him to a Writers Guild workshop on how to write and sell a Hallmark movie. And, eventually, to concrete.

It makes a peculiar sort of sense. Or perhaps I’ve simply spent too long going rabbit holes on Wikipedia.

The Hallmark workshop is a magnificent introduction to the machinery of commercial storytelling. Romances must be aspirational. There are formulas, conventions, and reassuringly predictable emotional beats. In an industry where such films routinely outperform far more prestigious productions, now is apparently not the time for Ken Burns or The Sopranos. Wilson, meanwhile, wants to make a documentary about the second most used material on the planet, a subject greeted by potential financiers with something approaching rigor mortis.

How much of this is genuine artistic anxiety, and how much is Wilson sending himself up? His diffident, slightly helpless persona is so beautifully sustained that it becomes almost impossible to separate the man from the performance. When he approaches Michael Imperioli for financing advice, or attempts to interest baffled Italians in the concrete of the Pantheon, the comedy derives as much from Wilson’s apparent sincerity as from the absurdity of the situation. He’s either an astonishingly guileless filmmaker or a brilliantly calculating one. I suspect the answer is some ingenious, perhaps impossible, combination of both.

The film’s ostensible subject emerges from a botched attempt to repair a leak in his home, prompting Wilson to reflect on how embarrassing it is to know so little about something occupying so much of his visual environment. From here, the narrative expands, contracts and wanders off in directions no reasonable person could anticipate.

Concrete leads to pavements, pavements to chewing gum, chewing gum to a specialist removal business whose proprietor also produces his own branded wine. Elsewhere, there’s a gruelling 3,100-mile race around a single New York block, a Roman wax museum whose historical celebrities have been given horrifying AI-generated animations, and a business dedicated to preserving the tattooed skin of deceased loved ones. There’s also a contractual stipulation that Wilson mustn’t disparage concrete, which raises the irresistible question of what, precisely, constitutes defamation of a building material.

Wilson’s curiosity is infectious. He has an affectionate eye for human eccentricity and a gift for eliciting fascinating details from people who might otherwise pass entirely unnoticed. He’s also very funny. His seemingly inexhaustible archive of street footage allows him to punctuate observations with surreal visual non sequiturs, unexpected juxtapositions and perfectly judged sight gags. One particularly inspired cut takes us from the importance of keeping poured concrete smooth to an iPhone playing John Mayer’s Your Body Is a Wonderland. It’s an atrocious joke, executed exquisitely.

There’s something of Nathan Fielder in Wilson’s cultivated awkwardness and the uncertainty surrounding his intentions, but whereas Fielder often constructs elaborate scenarios to reveal the absurdities of human behaviour, Wilson finds those absurdities already flourishing in the wild. His approach feels more observational, more generous, if hardly less manipulative. The apparent spontaneity conceals an extraordinary degree of editorial control. This is free association with a formidable sense of comic timing.

https://youtube.com/watch?v=2y7lRgA9Ar8%3Fsi%3DZH064_yJhOfKyhZL

Not every digression is equally rewarding, and at 101 minutes the film occasionally mistakes breadth for depth. Some of its more substantial concerns, particularly the politics of affordable housing, urban decay and the environmental costs of construction, deserve greater scrutiny than Wilson seems prepared to give them. His refusal to stay on any one subject can be liberating, but also frustrating. Fascinating avenues open up, only to be abandoned in favour of the next curiosity. There’s a nagging suspicion that the film’s methodology allows it to evade its own most difficult questions, whatever they might be.

Yet the longer it continues, the more these disparate fragments begin to acquire a cumulative significance. Concrete, supposedly the embodiment of permanence, is everywhere cracking, crumbling or being torn up and replaced. Ancient Roman structures survive while relatively recent buildings are already deteriorating. We devote enormous resources to constructing things that may not outlast us, while sometimes preserving the most unlikely relics of those who have gone before. What deserves to survive? What will survive regardless? And how much control do we have over the distinction?

These questions acquire an unexpectedly human dimension through Wilson’s friendship with Jack, an ageing musician whose determination to keep making and performing music offers a touching counterpoint to the director’s own artistic uncertainty. A prospective investor’s suggestion that the film might benefit from a celebrity musician instead leads Wilson to someone considerably less marketable, but infinitely more interesting. Gradually, what began as another apparently arbitrary detour becomes something approaching the emotional heart of the film.

There’s a wonderfully subversive quality to this. Wilson spends much of the running time resisting the formulaic storytelling prescribed by the Hallmark workshop, only to discover some of its essential ingredients in the unlikeliest places. Love, loss, perseverance and the possibility of renewal are all present, although real lives are considerably less obliging than television screenplays. Perhaps the formula isn’t inherently dishonest. Perhaps it’s simply what happens when we attempt to impose some order on experiences that stubbornly resist it.

The film’s other encounters with celebrity are less edifying. An extravagant GQ dinner involving Kim Kardashian, Jacob Elordi and a deliciously incongruous Tim Robinson finds Wilson rubbing shoulders with a world whose artificiality seems almost beyond parody. I came away liking practically everyone in the room a little less. Wilson’s presence also raises interesting questions about his own position: the supposedly marginal eccentric has become enough of a celebrity to gain entry to precisely the sort of environment his filmmaking quietly satirises.

For all its apparent randomness, The History of Concrete is ultimately concerned with the things we build, the things we lose, and the strange, often futile efforts we make to preserve them. It is also about the creative process itself, and the uncomfortable necessity of finding a form for experiences that don’t arrive conveniently packaged as narratives. Wilson is making a film about concrete while trying to work out how to make a film about concrete, and the two pursuits become increasingly inseparable.

Whether this all adds up to a coherent thesis is another question. Does it need to? The film has considerably more scope than depth, but there’s a richness in its accumulation of incident, a generosity towards the absurdities of ordinary existence, and an occasional, startling poignancy. It doesn’t always know when to linger, but it certainly knows where to look.

Somewhere along the way, I stopped taking notes. Not because I’d lost interest, but because I was enjoying myself too much to keep demanding that every diversion justify its existence. There’s something rather wonderful about surrendering to Wilson’s wandering curiosity, following one unlikely connection to another without knowing where, or indeed whether, any of them will lead.

And perhaps that’s the point. Life rarely follows a satisfying narrative structure. We stumble from one preoccupation to the next, pursuing connections, accumulating experiences, constructing meaning after the fact. Some things endure, others disappear, and we seldom know which apparently insignificant moments will turn out to matter.

Oh, goddamnit.

Author: robertmwallis

Graduate of Royal Holloway and the London Film School. Formerly Film & TV Editor of The Metropolist, Official Sidekick at A Place to Hang Your Cape, and co-host of The Movie RobCast podcast. Current member of the Online Film Critics Society.